Like Natasha, Kelley is also rumored to not have been at Women Tell All, but unlike Natasha, Kelley got a lot more time with Peter throughout the season. They had met before, and she seemed very different from most of the other women. She's a 28 year-old attorney who got a weird edit towards the end of her time on the show, but many fans have been calling for her to be the next lead. She's smart, sensible, and has a lot less of an Instagram model vibe than most other contestants (in a good way).